Tag: Schism
-
On Rachel Mastrogiacomo’s Cancellation: The SSPX Question Everyone Avoids
Rachel Mastrogiacomo’s conference cancellation raises questions about her reported SSPX ties, ecclesiastical authority, and the difference between defending Catholic Tradition and supporting disobedience to the Church. Read more…
-
The Montanists and Their “Uncontrolled Madness”
The Montanists’ ecstatic “prophecy” and uncontrolled madness offer a warning for today, as some charismatic sects likewise equate emotional manifestations with the Holy Spirit’s presence. Read more…
-
John Salza on SSPX Sympathizers: ‘They’re Almost Worse’
John Salza argues that while some Catholics who attend SSPX chapels solely for liturgical reasons may lack imputability, non-SSPX influencers who publicly promote the Society’s doctrinal positions may demonstrate formal adherence to schism and be considered excommunicated in the Church’s external forum. Read more…
-
Fr. Gerald Murray: SSPX’s Appeal Does Not Overturn the Excommunication Decree
Fr. Gerald Murray explains that the SSPX’s preliminary recourse does not overturn or nullify the excommunication decree. It merely requests administrative review while the Dicastery considers whether to withdraw or uphold it. Read more…
-
Why SSPX Confession and Matrimony Are Invalid Now
Why SSPX Confession and Matrimony Are Invalid Now has become one of the most debated questions following the Vatican’s 2026 explanatory note. This article explains the canonical reasons behind the Holy See’s conclusion, why the issue concerns validity rather than liceity, and why I am saddened by the division among Catholics and the differing opinions… Read more…
-
Fr. Gerald Murray Opines: SSPX Decree Is Canonically Defective
Father Gerald Murray asserts that the Vatican’s decree excommunicates six SSPX bishops but does not formally declare the remaining priests and laity excommunicated. He critiques the explanatory note for overstepping legal boundaries and argues penal laws must specify actions for clarity. Read more…
-
What SSPX Laypeople Should Do to Return to the Catholic Church
This article calls SSPX laypeople to return to the Catholic Church, explaining who needs reconciliation and outlining the Vatican’s process for restoring full communion through the local bishop. Read more…
-
SSPX Bishops, Priests and Laity Excommunicated: What Every Catholic Should Do Now
The SSPX’s unauthorized episcopal consecrations have grave canonical implications and threaten Church unity. Catholics should remain faithful to the Pope, avoid SSPX influence, pray for reconciliation, and preserve authentic Tradition in full communion with the Church. Read more…
-
“Please Don’t Do This”: Scott Hahn and Franciscan University Theologians to SSPX
On June 25, 2026, Scott Hahn and Franciscan University leaders urged the SSPX to cancel its planned unauthorized bishop consecrations, warning it could deepen their separation from the Church and calling for renewed dialogue with the Holy See. Read more…
-
On Bishop Schneider’s “Core Questions” Regarding the SSPX
My reaction to Bishop Schneider’s five core claims on the SSPX and his critique of those who do not fully align with the Society is that they frame a complex issue in a strongly one-sided way. Read more…