Rachel Mastrogiacomo was invited to speak at the Restore Tradition Women’s Conference, held at a Catholic church in Littleton, Colorado, on September 25–26, 2026. She had been advertised as a speaker long before the event. However, according to a recent investigative report by Hiraeth in Exile, her participation had already raised concerns because of her reported connections to the Society of Saint Pius X (SSPX).
Rachel eventually took the stage, but her presentation was reportedly interrupted twice. The stated reason was that her allotted time had expired. She subsequently left the venue, and her name was later removed from the conference’s online schedule. The report also presents leaked emails suggesting that the host parish and the Archdiocese of Denver had been involved in discussions about her participation.
The full circumstances of her interruption and departure still deserve clarification. Rachel’s supporters understandably feel that she was disrespected and unfairly treated. SSPX sympathizers will naturally argue that she was silenced for telling the truth about the Church. I have followed Rachel’s work for some time, I even help promote her book The Devil in Rome in my own little ways, and I appreciate her willingness to speak about difficult issues, particularly clerical abuse and the importance of Catholic Tradition. So I know she always tells the truth.
The real question is not simply whether Rachel was treated unfairly. It is whether her reported association with the SSPX raises legitimate concerns about her suitability to speak at an event hosted on Catholic Church property.
The SSPX is not just another traditional Catholic organization. Its unauthorized episcopal consecrations in 1988 resulted in a declaration of schism by the Holy See. Its decision to proceed with further unauthorized episcopal consecrations in July 2026 has renewed serious concerns about its relationship with the Church’s hierarchy. The Church’s canonical position on the SSPX and the consequences of its actions should not be dismissed simply because the Society promotes the Traditional Latin Mass.
Yet this is precisely what many SSPX sympathizers tend to overlook. They will readily question the conduct of the archdiocese, the parish, or the conference organizers, but they often refuse to confront the implications of defending a group that persists in acting against the authority of the Pope.
The conference was held in a Catholic parish within the Archdiocese of Denver. The organizers were therefore not operating in a vacuum. The local bishop has legitimate ecclesiastical responsibilities for Catholic activities within his diocese, and the parish has a responsibility to ensure that events hosted on its premises are consistent with the Church’s teachings and discipline. This does not mean that every decision by a bishop is automatically right or that speakers should be treated without respect. It does mean that ecclesiastical oversight is a legitimate part of Catholic life.
If I were the local bishop, I would also have serious reservations about inviting speakers who publicly defend the SSPX’s disobedience and challenge the Church’s authority in ways that risk normalizing schism. This concern would extend to figures such as Michael Matt, Matt Gaspers, Peter Kwasniewski, and John-Henry Westen, insofar as their public positions defend or justify the SSPX’s actions. This is not about silencing people simply because they are traditionalists. It is about recognizing the difference between defending Catholic Tradition and defending disobedience to the Church.
The SSPX’s July 2026 episcopal consecrations, despite Pope Leo XIV’s efforts to prevent them, make this issue even more serious. The now-excommunicated Society chose to proceed despite the Holy See’s objections. The Pope even pleaded with the Society not to proceed with the illicit consecrations. Such actions cannot be justified merely by claiming to preserve Tradition. Catholic fidelity requires more than adherence to traditional liturgical practices; it also requires communion with the Church and respect for legitimate ecclesiastical authority.
Rachel’s response to the incident was understandable. Anyone who feels publicly humiliated or disrespected has a right to explain what happened. However, I believe her response could have addressed the more important issue as well. If she has indeed maintained a relationship with or supported the SSPX, she could have used the opportunity to clarify her position. If she is no longer associated with the Society, she could have made that clear to the public.
Simply focusing on the way she was treated risks diverting attention from the underlying ecclesiastical issue. We should be able to acknowledge that someone may have been treated unfairly while also questioning the positions that may have contributed to the controversy.
There is also a practical solution for traditionalist speakers who wish to discuss controversial issues without being subject to the restrictions of a diocesan venue. They can organize events in hotels, theaters, or other privately rented spaces. If SSPX sympathizers have the resources to organize conferences and raise funds, they can also arrange independent venues rather than expecting Catholic parishes to accommodate every position they promote.
It is unreasonable to expect a Catholic parish to provide its facilities while dismissing the legitimate authority and responsibilities of the local bishop. Those who publicly challenge the Church’s authority should not be surprised when their positions raise concerns among the very ecclesiastical authorities responsible for safeguarding the faithful.
Ultimately, the solution is not to create a separate Catholic identity built around resistance to the hierarchy. It is to remain faithful to the Church, even when we disagree with particular decisions of its leaders. We can defend the Traditional Latin Mass, promote reverent liturgy, criticize abuses, and call for genuine reform without endorsing schism or disobedience.
I sincerely hope Rachel will clarify her relationship with the SSPX, if the reported connection is accurate. I also hope the conference organizers will explain why she was interrupted and why her name was subsequently removed from the schedule. Both matters deserve honest answers. If she does have a connection with the SSPX, she should humbly acknowledge that this may have been part of the reason for the controversy. If she is not connected to the SSPX, she could have made that clear to the organizers in advance.
Recommended Books on Amazon
- Rachel Mastrogiacomo (2025). The Devil in Rome
- John Salza and Robert Siscoe (2022). True or False Pope: Refuting Sedevacantism and other Modern Errors
- Fr. Chad A Ripperger (2013). The Binding Force of Tradition
Rachel Answered…
Ave Maria!
Thank you for promoting my book. May God reward you abundantly.
It is no secret that my husband led our family to the SSPX in August 2021, shortly after Traditionis Custodes was issued motu proprio by Francis on July 16, 2021. There are even public photographs of my family with Dr. Taylor Marshall and Kennedy Hall hanging out after a high-profile SSPX event.
More importantly, I never concealed our family’s position but was completely transparent with the conference coordinator about our relationship with the SSPX, and originally, there was no objection whatsoever.
Later, after the purported “excommunications,” the matter was taken to people very high up in the archdiocese. For three or four weeks, I did not know whether my invitation to speak still stood. Ultimately, according to the conference coordinator, the archbishop granted permission for me to speak.
These are simple facts. I have the receipts. The correspondence, the timeline, and the facts can all be produced. Perhaps they ought to be.
It is wrong and deceptive to suggest that I have been secretive or that I was invited under false pretenses. I did not conceal my position. I was welcomed to speak after having been fully transparent about it. If you have a problem with this, then you should take it up with the conference coordinator, Jane Brennan, or the Archdiocese of Denver.
There is another detail that seems particularly important.
If you actually listen to my speech, you will notice that when I addressed the deficiencies of the Novus Ordo Mass, for instance, I did not quote Archbishop Lefebvre. I quoted Pope Benedict XVI.
So perhaps the greater question here is not what people have assumed, repeated, or whispered about me.
The question is much simpler:
“What, exactly, did Rachel Mastrogiacomo say aloud at an FSSP parish that caused this heinous cancellation and coverup?”
I am perfectly willing to let that question speak for itself. It cuts to the heart of the situation.
Ad Jesum per Mariam,
Rachel
My Response…
Thanks, Rachel. Information about your SSPX connection was lacking in publicly available sources, or perhaps I simply hadn’t come across the content where you shared your affiliation with them. This is the first time I’ve seen you confirm it.
You may say that you never concealed this fact, but I believe you should have made it more public, especially after the scandalous actions of the Society this year.
I have nothing more to say about what really happened at the conference. The fact that you continue to receive spiritual nourishment from the SSPX, including its illicit Eucharistic celebrations and now invalid confessions, is a serious concern for me given the Church’s position regarding the Society. It is also difficult for me to reconcile this with your devotion to St. Thérèse and the other saints whose intercession you seek. They never lived their spiritual lives outside the Church’s sacramental discipline.
To be clear, we both love the Traditional Latin Mass, and I have criticized Pope Francis and Traditionis Custodes for restricting the TLM. But loving the liturgy more than what the Church asks of us makes things shaky, like building a house on sand. When the storm comes, as it did with the SSPX episcopal consecrations, the foundation can give way.
God bless you too.
This post has reached Rachel and thousands of Catholics, and instead of simply acknowledging that her connection to the SSPX could have been a factor in what happened, she doubled down, telling everyone again her story of persecution at the conference.
Many people are falling for her drama, with excommunicated SSPXers rallying behind her. And let’s be honest about who benefits from this narrative: not the Church, but the SSPX and those who want to portray the SSPX as the persecuted party.
In fact, by calling the SSPX’s ‘excommunications’ “purported” only shows how disconnected her position has become from the Church’s position. “Purported”? Is Rachel now suggesting that the Church’s determination that SSPX bishops, priests, and some of the laity incurred excommunication for schism is somehow open to dispute? To me, that is effectively a slap in the face of the Mother Church.
Does Rachel Still Deserves Support?
As a Catholic who rejects both modernism and radical traditionalism, I can still point to one thing Rachel has to offer that I believe is worth listening to: her testimony about the abuse she experienced from a cleric in Rome. Listen to her interviews about it. Read her book. That is a serious matter, and her testimony deserves to be heard.
Beyond that, however, given her current connection to the SSPX, I personally would not consume her other content. I have no interest in feeding anything that ultimately benefits the SSPX while undermining confidence in the authority of the Catholic Church. Remaining associated with the SSPX after its excommunications is a grave matter, and SSPX priests do not have the ordinary faculties of priests in full communion with the Church to validly absolve from sins.
If I am going to listen to someone for my spiritual growth, I would rather listen to Catholics who are striving to live virtuously, remain faithful to the Church, and regularly approach the Sacrament of Reconciliation. I do not need spiritual guidance from someone who remains attached to a group that rejects the authority of the Church.
Recommended Books on Amazon
- Rachel Mastrogiacomo (2025). The Devil in Rome
- John Salza and Robert Siscoe (2022). True or False Pope: Refuting Sedevacantism and other Modern Errors
- Fr. Chad A Ripperger (2013). The Binding Force of Tradition



Leave a Reply