The Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments recently published an account of its meeting with the Bishops of Panama during their ad limina Apostolorum visit. One section has attracted considerable attention because it mentions receiving Holy Communion kneeling or in the hand and the use of veils by women.
Some Catholic sources have interpreted this as the Vatican condemning traditional practices. But is that really what the text says?
After reading the report, I believe we need a more balanced interpretation. Here are the main points discussed during the meeting between the Dicastery and the Panamanian bishops. Notice that they emphasize a more Catholic approach to these matters rather than a protestantizing of the Sacraments.
On Sunday Celebrations Without a Priest
This practice is already familiar in many parts of Asia and Latin America. Priests sometimes serve remote villages, travel difficult terrain, or minister to more communities than they can reach for Sunday Mass. I have discussed this in a previous post Scarcity of Priests is Real.
Communities gather for approved Sunday celebrations led by a designated layperson. These are not Masses but communal prayer celebrations, usually centered on the Liturgy of the Word and including the distribution of already-consecrated Holy Communion. Their purpose is to help communities sanctify Sunday when a priest is unavailable, not to replace the Mass.
On Marriage: Against Commercialization
The report warns against a commercial mentality surrounding the Sacrament of Marriage. A Catholic wedding should not become primarily a social spectacle in which expenses and appearances overshadow the sacrament. Beautiful weddings are not inherently wrong, but couples must understand marriage as a sacred covenant and lifelong vocation.
On Reconciliation: Against Individualism
Confession should not be reduced to a therapeutic conversation or a source of emotional relief. Although priests may offer counsel, the sacrament fundamentally concerns repentance, forgiveness of sins, and reconciliation with God and the Church. Psychological support has its place, but it must not obscure the supernatural reality of sacramental absolution.
On the Liturgy: Preserving Unity
The report emphasizes uniformity in liturgical celebrations as an expression of ecclesial unity. The liturgy is not the private possession of a priest or community. Legitimate adaptations are possible, but they must respect the Church’s liturgical discipline. I know Panama is not particularly friendly toward the Traditional Latin Mass, but it is clear that the report does not condemn traditional elements in the Mass.
On Liturgical Singing: Beyond Emotionalism
Liturgical music should serve sacred worship and express sound Catholic doctrine. The report cautions against individualism, mere emotionalism, and local folklore. This does not mean rejecting legitimate cultural expressions; rather, these must be appropriate to the liturgy and consistent with the faith.
On Eucharistic Adoration: Maintaining Its Proper Character
Eucharistic adoration should not become detached from the celebration of the Eucharist or excessively individualistic. The report also cautions against additional gestures, prayers, and responses that compromise the sobriety proper to the Roman Rite. Devotion is important, but it must be guided by the Church’s liturgical discipline.
On Communion Reception: What Did the Vatican Actually Say?
The report mentions receiving Communion kneeling AND in the hand. Obviously, these refer to two different practices, since people do not ordinarily kneel while receiving Communion in the hand. Therefore, the statement can be understood as referring to groups that raise issues concerning both the practice of receiving Communion kneeling AND the practice of receiving Communion in the hand.
What the report criticizes is the instrumentalization of the Eucharistic celebration through these controversies. It does not explicitly declare that kneeling to receive Communion is wrong, nor does it declare that receiving Communion in the hand is wrong.
We can defend kneeling without condemning everyone who receives in the hand, just as we should not ridicule those who kneel.
On Veiling: Is Wearing a Veil the Problem?
The same distinction applies to women wearing veils. The report mentions the use of the veil in the context of groups that provoke division, but it does not explicitly say that wearing a veil, by itself, causes division. Women who veil should not be ridiculed, and women who do not veil should not automatically be judged less devout. The problem is turning a legitimate devotional practice into a test of Catholic orthodoxy that the Church has not imposed.
What Balanced Catholics Should Remember
When elements of Tradition are discussed, we should defend traditional practices while acknowledging legitimate concerns about divisive behavior. We should read Vatican statements carefully rather than condemn them automatically or interpret them as attacks on Catholic Tradition without sufficient evidence. Our responsibility is to preserve the Deposit of Faith, promote reverent worship, respect legitimate liturgical practices, and remain united in Christ and His Church.
THIS NOVEMBER ONLY…
A Humble and Honest Plea
Epistles is an independent Catholic blog dedicated to promoting a balanced Catholic position and sharing reflections on the faith and the Church. It is a personal apostolate maintained without sponsorship or regular funding.
Epistles’ website fees are due this month. The website is gradually outgrowing the limits of its current (cheapest) hosting package, so I need to raise at least US$115 to cover the renewal and upgrade fees. Any excess will go to The Sisters of Mary School, also known as World Villages for Children, founded by Venerable Aloysius Schwartz, where poor high school students study and live for free while being formed in Catholic values. Bishop Joseph Strickland describes The Sisters of Mary as “a microcosm of what the Church needs to do in our culture.”
No money received through direct contributions will be used for my personal expenses, not even my electricity or internet bills. As Proverbs 15:27 reminds us, “He who is greedy for unjust gain brings trouble on his household.”
If you are in a state of grace, share my commitment to promoting a balanced Catholic position, and are able to offer some financial support, I would be sincerely grateful for any contribution, no matter how small. You may send your contribution via paypal.me/epistles.
This request will remain at the top of the blog only until November 30, 2026. After that date, the PayPal links will be deactivated. I will post updates in the comments on any contributions received and how the funds are used, even if no contributions are received.
Thank you for your support and prayers. May God bless us all.
Sincerely,
Jonel Esto
Author of Epistles Online
Leave a Reply