On the “Demonic” Screams at Padre Pio Shrine During Cardinal Simoni’s Mass

Viral footage from a Mass celebrated by Albanian Cardinal Ernest Simoni at the Shrine of Saint Pio in Italy has sparked claims of a demonic manifestation after unusual sounds were heard during an exorcism prayer. However, Catholics are urged to exercise discernment, consider plausible natural explanations, and avoid sensationalism in the absence of official confirmation.

Spliced videos from a Mass on November 17, 2026, at the Shrine of Saint Pio of Pietrelcina in San Giovanni Rotondo, Italy, have gone viral on social media. The Mass was celebrated by Cardinal Ernest Simoni, an Albanian cardinal known for surviving religious persecution and imprisonment under Albania’s former communist regime. At the conclusion of the Mass, Cardinal Simoni recited in Latin the Exorcismus in Satanam et Angelos Apostaticos, the exorcism prayer published by order of Pope Leo XIII in 1890.

Many reports claim that during Padre Pio TV’s live broadcast, unusual screams, groans, and other vocalizations could be heard in the background as Cardinal Simoni recited the prayer. The clip has since circulated widely on social media, with many posts describing the sounds as a demonic roar or evidence of a demonic manifestation. Interestingly, I checked the Padre Pio TV YouTube channel and noticed that the original recording of the Mass is no longer available.

I have no problem acknowledging a genuine demonic manifestation if there is sufficient reason to believe that one has occurred. However, we must remember to use both faith and reason, not one at the expense of the other.

My take? I don’t believe we have sufficient grounds to call this a demonic manifestation.

And I say this partly because I am a father of a child with autism. When my son has a meltdown, the sounds he makes can be quite unusual, and sometimes there is simply no way to stop them immediately. I have also attended Masses where parents bring along family members with special needs, some of whom have more severe conditions than my son and require wheelchairs. Through these experiences, I have become familiar with the different sounds and vocalizations that some individuals with special needs may make.

So, it is entirely possible that the voice heard in the video came from someone with special needs. Considering that this is a shrine visited by large numbers of pilgrims, including elderly people and those with special needs, this is a natural possibility worth considering. Unless the shrine prohibits sick, elderly, or otherwise disadvantaged people from entering the church—which is highly unlikely—we should not dismiss this explanation.

Furthermore, as far as I know, the Padre Pio Shrine has not issued an official statement identifying the sounds or confirming any demonic manifestation. The video itself does not establish the source of the sounds, much less prove that someone was possessed or that a supernatural phenomenon occurred. If there are genuine grounds for concern, the matter should be investigated by the appropriate ecclesiastical authorities rather than decided through social media speculation.

What is important is that we should not immediately attribute unusual vocalizations to demonic activity when there are plausible natural explanations. Faith and reason must work together. Sharing unverified supernatural or preternatural claims does not help the Church. Instead, it risks encouraging superstition and drawing people toward sensationalism rather than genuine Catholic faith.

Again, I am not dismissing the reality of demonic activity. I am simply saying that not everything unusual is supernatural, and not every strange sound is demonic. Let us exercise discernment before sharing such claims. Our Catholic faith deserves better than sensationalism.

Advertisements
Category:

Leave a Reply

Advertisements
Jonel Esto Author Epistles Online

I help promote the work of trusted Catholic voices who are faithful to the Deposit of Faith while avoiding both modernist distortions and extreme traditionalism. If you know of a book, movie, or other resource that reflects this balanced approach, leave a message below. I’d be happy to learn more and explore how I can help share it with others.

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Advertisements

If balanced Catholicism matters to you, subscribe to receive email notifications whenever new content is published on Epistles. Don’t forget to check your inbox and confirm your subscription to start receiving updates!

“The sincere and zealous reformer will avoid extremes and will always be united in the closest bonds with the Church and Christ, her Head.”
– Pope St. Pius X, ES 29

Discover more from EPISTLES

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading