Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) Catholics gathered in Rome for the annual Summorum Pontificum pilgrimage, hoping to celebrate the traditional liturgy and express their communion with the Successor of St. Peter.
Following reports of last-minute changes, self-proclaimed defenders of Tradition like Peter Kwasniewski launched angry criticism of the Vatican, and many accepted his account without further examination. But Mountain Butorac of The Catholic Traveler, drawing on decades of experience organizing pilgrimages, offered a much-needed reality check.
Kudos to Butorac for helping clarify the situation. His statement sheds light on what actually happened and why we should be careful about interpreting every disappointment as persecution or conspiracy.
Here are three posts from three different individuals to help you understand the controversy, defend the Church, and avoid further confusion.
Michael Haynes: Some theories are circulating online about the Latin Mass pilgrimage, spread by people unconnected with it.
Some clarity below —
Organisers asked for permission for the Vatican Mass, via a letter delivered directly to Pope Leo by Bishop Schneider in December. The pilgrimage is in its 15th year, and is always held on the same date.
Organisers received no answer about the Mass until August, when the Secretariat of State replied to say they could not have Mass in the Vatican. Pilgrimage organisers then announced publicly that no Mass would take place in the Vatican.
Instead, pilgrims would process into the Vatican at 1pm on the Saturday, and then go to St Mary Major for a 3pm Mass. Permission for the procession into the Vatican was granted in April 2026.
Weeks after this, in September, St Peter’s announced an event taking place at 3:30pm at the Altar of the Chair (used by the pilgrimage last year for Mass).
Then this week – just yesterday I am told – organisers received another letter from the Secretariat of State informing them they could not even process into the Vatican as planned, and as permitted since April. Basilica events are not the prerogative of the Secretariat but of the Archpriest & the Fabric of St Peter’s: hence why the Secretariat of State’s involvement is so strange.
On Saturday, pilgrims walked through the streets up to the obelisk in St. Peter’s Square – accompanied by Italian state police – where they were stopped by the Vatican as this was the limit of the Italian police’s jurisdiction.
Then they were informed that their usage of St Mary Major’s had changed: they could only be inside for an hour.
Thus meaning that the planned and authorised pontifical solemn Mass would have to be a low Mass.
Also St Mary Major’s informed pilgrimage that no official photos could be taken.
Peter Kwasniewski: The Vatican personnel’s decisions about the Summorum Pontificum pilgrimage are among the most petty and vindictive I have ever seen. Having granted permissions, they rescinded them at the last moment.
- They forced Vespers to begin earlier so that many would miss it.
- They disallowed the pilgrims from entering St. Peter’s in procession to profess their Catholic faith and union with the successor of Peter (!).
- They declared last-minute that the Mass at St. Mary’s could last “only one hour,” which, of course, obliterated the carefully planned solemn pontifical Mass.
- They said “no official photographs,” in an echo of Roche’s “no listings of the TLM in bulletins.”
Such absurd and offensive steps have predictable consequences: they make the Vatican look desperate and out of touch; they alienate and radicalize traditionalists; they rhetorically strengthen the SSPX’s case. If the Vatican’s desire is to create further division, polarization, and resentment while fueling the traditionalist fire, they have done a brilliant job!
The Catholic Traveler: Good grief. Again, I attend the TLM in Rome with the ICKSP and with the FSSP when I’m in the States. I have attended this TLM pilgrimage many times over the years. I am NOT a journalist or blogger who gets paid to rage. I am, however, someone who has been organizing pilgrimages like this for decades and knows exactly how the Vatican and the churches work.
The news over the last few days is that the TLM pilgrimage Mass was not allowed in Saint Peter’s Basilica, that the Vatican threw together an event to block them, that the group was denied entry into the basilica to pray, and that they were only allowed one hour at Saint Mary Major at the last minute, with no photos.
Let me break this down…
Celebrations for the 800th anniversary of the death of Saint Francis were being planned as early as 2021. Meetings took place with Pope Francis in 2022 to discuss the events. In January 2025, the Italian government met with Vatican officials to plan the events. In January 2026, Vatican News referenced planned events to take place throughout the year. So despite what some are saying, the Franciscan event that is happening today was not thrown together to block this Mass at the last minute. In fact, this event coincides with a huge event that starts tomorrow in Assisi, where 5,000 people have registered and which Pope Leo was originally scheduled to attend.
When the organizers requested the Mass for this day, they were told the altar was already reserved and offered another day or another location. They chose another location, Saint Mary Major. No scandal.
As for the procession, the group was not banned from entering. They were not allowed to process in. They could not carry their flags and banners and would have to enter through security like everyone else. If you check the photos, you’ll see that the line at that time was over an hour long. So if they arrived at their scheduled time of 1 p.m., it would have been difficult to get through security and across town in time for their 3 p.m. Mass.
Props to the PR people who positioned the group for a photo in front of the walls set up for construction of the Nativity scene instead of moving them over a few feet for an unobstructed view of the basilica!
Last year, we were able to process in because there was a dedicated entrance for the Jubilee with very little wait. Anyone could process in (unfortunately), which is why we ended up with some inappropriate processions. But that was an exception during the Jubilee. Normally, groups cannot just process beyond the piazza, as was the case today.
As for the Mass at Saint Mary Major, they allow one hour for Mass. I have been here with cardinals leading pilgrimages of hundreds of people. Do you know how much time they were allowed for Mass? One hour. Saint Mary Major says on their Mass reservation form and in their confirmation emails that private groups are allowed one hour. Could they have made an exception? Sure, but they don’t usually for cardinals bringing busloads of people, so why would they here?
And for the photos during Mass, permission to use a professional photographer has to be requested well in advance. Did the organizers know this and make the proper request? I don’t know. Professional photos on Vatican property, including Saint Peter’s Basilica, Saint Peter’s Square, Saint Mary Major, Saint John Lateran, Saint Paul Outside the Walls, and the Scala Santa, require special permission. I’ve been making these requests for years. It’s simple, but getting a reply takes time. It is the Vatican, after all. So perhaps they did not have permission or even ask for permission.
There is plenty to question in the Church, but if you’re not looking for clicks, this looks more like poor planning and poor communication, possibly on both sides, than some grand conspiracy.
Recommended Books:
- Discovering the Latin Mass: A Travel Guide for the Curious by Eduard Habsburg
- The Lamb’s Supper: The Mass as Heaven on Earth by Scott Hahn
- Latin-English Booklet Missal For Praying The Traditional Mass by Coalition in Support of Ecclesia Dei
Leave a Reply