Dr. Peter Kreeft defines true freedom not as the absence of all constraints, but as “freedom from” sin (the obstacle) and “freedom for” God (the goal).
In other words, true freedom is not just doing whatever you want. It means being free from sin and free to choose what is good—especially God, who is truth, love, and joy. Following God’s commandments and trusting Him and his agents may feel limiting, but they actually help you become truly free, because they lead you to what is best for you.
Dr. Peter Kreeft on True Freedom
True freedom is freedom from and freedom for: freedom from an obstacle to your goal, and that obstacle is sin; and freedom for your goal, and that goal is God, and His truth, and His love, and His joy. So if God gives you commandments, and if those commandments are transmitted through His agents… in contemplative monasteries, even in the West, is the authority of the abbot. Well, that’s the voice of God, and obedience to authority is the key to real freedom.
That sounds wrong to us, because obedience sounds like what a slave has to do and a master doesn’t have to do. But, as even Hegel pointed out, the master-slave relationship is almost the opposite of what it seems to be. The slave is free from addiction to the master; he doesn’t need the master. The master is not free from his addiction to the slave; he needs the slave. So really, the master is the slave, and if you’re rich, you’re the master. So it’s a very dangerous thing…
It’s a matter of trust. If you can’t trust your Father, who can you trust? And trust is not proof. If you have proof, you don’t need trust. I don’t need to trust that two and two are four, but I need to trust that God loves me—and that’s true. Freedom: the freedom to trust. I can choose to trust that God loves me despite the evidence.
Source: Dr. Peter Kreeft on suffering, true freedom & the Brothers Karamazov (2026, April 10)
Peter Kreeft Books on Amazon
- An Ocean Full of Angels – April 27, 2026
- The Two Greatest Novels Ever Written: The Wisdom of The Lord of the Rings and The Brothers Karamazov – December 8, 2025
- Philosophy: What Every Catholic Should Know – February 1, 2023
- Handbook of Catholic Apologetics: Reasoned Answers to Questions of Faith – June 18, 2009
Leave a Reply